The Healing Terrain Ep. 16 - Hormones and Toxicity: Why Balancing Hormones Fails with Dr. Tara Scott

The Healing Terrain Ep. 16 - Hormones and Toxicity: Why Balancing Hormones Fails with Dr. Tara Scott



Sign up for a practitioner account →

In Episode 16 of The Healing Terrain, Dr. Emily Hernandez welcomes Tara Scott, MD, for a conversation about why balancing hormones can fall short when the environment surrounding those hormones is overlooked.

Scott began her career as an OB-GYN before expanding into integrative and functional medicine. With more than two decades in hormone care, she works with patients across life stages, from teenagers with acne and irregular periods to women navigating perimenopause and menopause.

Her central message is that hormone health involves more than the amount of estrogen, progesterone, or testosterone on a lab report. It also involves how hormones are produced, how they signal, how they are metabolized, and what may be interfering along the way.

This episode explores how environmental exposures, gut health, stress, and individual physiology fit into a more complete approach to hormone support.

Look Beyond the Hormone Level

Scott describes seeing younger patients who are struggling with symptoms but have not found an approach that addresses their individual concerns. Her examples include acne, irregular cycles, and painful periods.

Hernandez points out that a symptom can be common without being something a patient should simply have to accept. Together, they emphasize listening to the person’s experience and looking more closely at the factors contributing to it.

Scott brings diet, environmental exposures, and differences in hormone metabolism into that assessment. She also discusses how age and life stage change the questions she asks.

The discussion sets up the episode’s larger theme: when hormone support is not producing the expected response, the next step is to understand what else is affecting the system.

Put Testing in Context

One of Scott’s first questions about a hormone test is when it was collected. For someone who is still cycling, the timing of the sample matters to the question being asked.

She explains that testing early in a cycle for fertility-related information serves a different purpose from evaluating progesterone after ovulation. In her practice, she considers cycle timing, the hormones measured, symptoms, and the person’s history together.

Scott also looks at the relationship among results. She describes asking where estrogen and progesterone fall within their respective ranges, rather than reviewing each number in isolation.

For Hernandez, the practical point is to keep the patient’s symptoms in the conversation even when results appear within a laboratory’s reference range. Scott’s approach is to use testing as part of an individualized assessment that also includes metabolic and thyroid health.

Understand How Environmental Exposures Affect Signaling

Scott uses a light-switch analogy to explain hormone receptors. A hormone normally helps turn a signal on or off. If another substance interacts with that receptor, the resulting signal may not reflect the hormone alone.

She describes endocrine disruptors as one reason to look beyond the amount of hormone being produced. Published laboratory research has demonstrated that certain environmental chemicals can activate estrogen-related signaling and interfere with androgen signaling in receptor-based assays.¹

Human research also connects environmental exposures with hormone levels. An analysis of NHANES 2011–2012 data found associations between several urinary phthalate metabolites and lower serum testosterone in specific age and sex groups, with particularly consistent associations among women ages 40–60.²

Scott also discusses enzymes involved in hormone production and metabolism, including aromatase, which converts testosterone to estradiol. Her explanation brings the conversation from hormone quantity to the pathways influencing hormone activity.

“So sometimes the answer isn’t necessarily give more estrogen or more testosterone,” she says.

Her focus is on understanding what may be interfering with the response, whether the person is using hormone therapy or another form of hormone support.

Follow How the Body Metabolizes Hormones

Scott compares the liver’s workload to traffic on a highway. In her explanation, environmental burden and the pathways involved in estrogen metabolism belong in the same assessment.

She discusses cytochrome P450 enzymes and COMT as parts of that broader metabolic picture. Hernandez connects the discussion with the importance of supporting the terrain in which hormones are working.

Scott describes using blood testing as a starting point, then considering additional information when it fits the person’s presentation. One example is urine testing that looks at estrogen metabolites.

“It’s more like looking at receipts,” she explains.

Her analogy is an accountant reviewing more than a bank balance. Knowing how much money is in the account does not show how it was spent. Similarly, she uses metabolite information to explore how hormones are being processed alongside the information available from blood testing.

Connect Gut Health With the Hormone Picture

The conversation also returns to the gut. Scott describes looking at digestive health and, when relevant to the patient, food sensitivities as part of her assessment.

Her approach varies with the concern in front of her. A teenager with acne may need a different evaluation from a woman in her thirties with cycle changes or a postmenopausal patient seeking hormone support.

Hernandez brings the microbiome into the discussion of communication among the gut, brain, and adrenal system. The speakers emphasize looking at the connected systems that influence how a person feels and responds to care.

For Scott, this broader approach developed over years in practice. She explains that her early work focused more heavily on testing and prescribing hormones. As her education and experience expanded, she began looking more closely at the factors shaping each patient’s response.

Include Thyroid and Adrenal Health

Although much of the episode focuses on sex hormones, Scott emphasizes that they do not operate separately from thyroid and adrenal hormones.

“We have to look at all of them,” she says.

She discusses estrogen’s relationship with hormone-binding proteins and why thyroid concerns can be part of the picture during perimenopause. A clinical study in postmenopausal women found that estrogen therapy increased thyroxine-binding globulin and, in women treated for hypothyroidism, could increase the need for thyroxine.³

Stress is another part of Scott’s clinical assessment. She describes observing its effect on patients’ hormone-related symptoms and responses, while Hernandez connects the discussion with the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal, or HPA, axis.

Together, they encourage a view of hormone health that includes the communication among these systems rather than focusing on one hormone at a time.

Match Support to the Person and Life Stage

Scott recognizes an important role for hormone therapy while emphasizing that the starting point differs from person to person. Someone who has had her ovaries removed has different needs from someone who is still cycling.

She discusses perimenopause as a time when symptoms need to be considered alongside the patient’s changing hormone patterns. In her approach, the presence of symptoms alone does not answer every question about which hormone or pathway needs attention.

She also emphasizes individual sensitivity. Two people can respond differently to the same intervention because their bodies handle it differently. Her goal is to understand that response within the context of the whole person.

The episode closes with Scott encouraging patients to advocate for themselves and seek a practitioner who will “treat you as an individual person.”

Hernandez brings that message into daily life: reducing environmental exposures can begin with small steps. Scott highlights attention to water, the home environment, and gut health as areas to bring into the broader conversation.

Practical Takeaways From the Conversation

Scott and Hernandez return to several themes throughout the episode:

·    Interpret hormone testing alongside symptoms, cycle timing, and personal history.

·    Consider environmental exposures when exploring hormone signaling and response.

·    Look at hormone metabolism as well as the amount of hormone present.

·    Include gut, metabolic, thyroid, and adrenal health in the assessment.

·    Match the approach to the person’s age, life stage, and sensitivity.

·    Take manageable steps to reduce environmental exposures and advocate for individualized care.

The episode’s answer to why balancing hormones can fail comes back to the terrain: the hormone itself is one part of a larger system. Scott’s approach asks what is influencing that system and what the individual needs for hormone support to work more effectively.

Listen to the Full Episode

Listen to Episode 16 of The Healing Terrain with Dr. Tara Scott and Dr. Emily Hernandez for the full conversation on hormones, toxicity, testing, and individualized care. Find the podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube.

References

1. Sohoni P, Sumpter JP. Several environmental oestrogens are also anti-androgens. Journal of Endocrinology. 1998;158(3):327–339. doi:10.1677/joe.0.1580327.

2. Meeker JD, Ferguson KK. Urinary phthalate metabolites are associated with decreased serum testosterone in men, women, and children from NHANES 2011–2012. The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism. 2014;99(11):4346–4352. doi:10.1210/jc.2014-2555.

3. Arafah BM. Increased need for thyroxine in women with hypothyroidism during estrogen therapy. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2001;344(23):1743–1749. doi:10.1056/NEJM200106073442302.

Disclaimer

This content is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for individualized medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.